I get the first page, but when I click on "next", all I get is: "How to buy an item" at the top and a blank page.
I am using Windows Vista (YUK - temporary, I guarantee) and Mozilla Firefox.
ON your USP:
I should NOT have to hunt for it. If I were a casual browser who reached your site by accident or referral, I would probably not have gone past the home page because there is nothing there that seemed any different than eBay.
Again, I find myself drawn into the criticism of someone`s business model, but I think that you are missing a big opportunity here by focusing on a small niche of buyers and sellers who are probably already well served by eBay.
First, your name: "Yard Sale Surfer" is misleading. My first thought was, great, yet another place to list or look for a yard sale. Digging deeper I find that your site has absolutely nothing to do with yard sales, but is yet another auction site. I only dug deeper because you asked for site critique, otherwise, I would have been gone. This is when I finally found your USP which I think is brilliant. I`ve never seen anything like it on the net. I think that you should protect it, run with it and not limit your scope to a tiny niche of baseball card swappers.
Just my opinion.
MannMade Digital Video