CookieMonster wrote:
JMCAUL, I simply said I can't agree with your position. I didn't agree then and I don't agree now. Can we just agree to disagree? 
Why is there so much advertising? Hmm. Advertising agencies aren't in the business of selling products, they're in the business of selling more advertising. Advertising is their product. Return on investment for advertising is notoriously difficult to determine. But don't take my word for it. If you're interested in reading about this, try The Fall Of Advertising ... and the Rise of P.R. by Al and Laura Ries. Al Ries is one of the world's foremost experts on marketing and branding. So is his daughter Laura. Try ries.com and check out their books. You can also check out Jennifer Rice at the following url:
http://www.mantrabrand.com/index.html
Here are some highlights from my post.
1. Using advertising to build a business is not only extremely expensive, it's extremely risky and best suited for companies with deep pockets. Public relations is a much better tool. [There are lots of marketing experts who agree with this. This isn't just my opinion. However, I imagine that lots of people who work in advertising will disagree with this position.]
2. What's most important to small business is continuous focus on the fundamentals. [Again, lots of experts agree with this and it's common sense.]
3. Brand strategy for new products and services requires clarity and focus above all. [Again, lots of experts agree with this and it's common sense.]
4. Will advertising help anyone grow a business that isn't in a position to scale its operations? That's cart before horse in my opinion. [Again, lots of experts agree with this and it's common sense.]
In fact advertising is cart before horse unless the business is fundamentally sound and well managed. What's the fastest way to kill a bad idea or a poorly implemented idea? Tell everyone about it.
Last, in my previous post, I said "If there is a correlation, please show me. Cite some statistics or something." I hope this didn't seem snarky. I'm simply asking for information. If there is a correlation, I certainly would like to know about it. Most business fail because they are started by individuals with little or no experience. Failure has nothing to do with advertising, marketing, public relations, or anything except inexperience.