Find us elsewhere
Join Now Member Login

Two business ideas and need some suggestions/advice

 
New Topic
Post Reply
Follow Topic
Page of 1
  • Author
  • Message
 
ckw1969

posts: 15

Jan 27, 2009 11:08 AM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
WARNING! This is will be long.
 
Good Morning, All.  I have been thinking about two different types of businesses: 
 
My first business idea is to have website to provide price comparisons on the area grocery and convenience stores.  There are a lot of price comparison sites and resources out there, but none specifically for grocery stores.  So I thought I could serve my community well by doing one for my area (DC/VA/MD). It would include:
 
Grocers
Wholesale Clubs (Sam`s, Costco, etc)
Convenience Stores (CVS, Rite-Aid, WalGreen`s)
 
The goal is simply to help people make better choices when shopping.  This is time consuming, because it requires putting in the UPC Bar Code for ALL items for all the stores, the prices and building the site so that if the item is on sale, or not at a particular store it can reflect that.  I will have to do a search on the price comparison sites to see how they`ve done to see if this worthwhile, or if I should take another approach.
 
The second idea is a little more complex and detailed.  I would like to combine two existing companies` ideals and take it to the next level.  Upromise (www.upromise.com) offers people and parents away to save for college (and I believe private school) by doing what they already do: purchasing items.  A certain percentage goes towards your account.
 
Coupon Mom (www.couponmom) offers many resources on how to save at your local grocery store, buying clothes,  receive free samples, donating to the poor and hungry, etc.
They are both doing really good things for good causes. 
 
One downside to Upromise is that a lot of the retailers are for purchases online only.
One downside to Coupon Mom is that you have to download specifics to print the coupons.
 
Upromise now offers ecoupons - You merely click on the coupons you want, and they go on your credit, debit or loyalty cards that you registered.  JACKPOT - No more cutting and organizing coupons.
 
Here is where I come in.  I would like to combine what Upromise and Coupon Mom does and create ecoupons so that people can just have the information go on there cards, not via email that still have to be printed out (unless buying online) but merely put on their loyalty or credit cards so that can slide and go.  I would like to work with people so that they can donate to a cause (like www.onecause.org) or just get the points. Right now ecoupons are for groceries only.  I would like to create them for all items possible.
 
What I don`t know is:
  • How to to make an ecoupon
  • How to approach the retailers to develop relationships (After all Upromise have established partnerships with the companies)
  • How to make sure I don`t do anything that copyright infringes (Upromise is not the only company that uses ecoupons, but I do want to be careful)
 
I would appreciate any comments and advice.
 
And sorry if this was long, but I DID warn you
 
Cheers,
 
Caroline
 
ckw19691/27/2009 11:07 AM
MattThomas

posts: 203

Jan 27, 2009 3:06 PM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
I definitely like your first idea a lot. I think it has a lot of promise, and would be especially useful in these economic times. Are you sure you will need to input all the bar codes? Maybe there would be an easier and less time consuming way to track prices? Maybe you can even start out by just having your local grocery stores send you price information or sales published in their circulars?

As for the second idea, I somewhat understand the concept, but I guess I`m not fully getting it. Maybe I`m just a little confused as to exactly what information would go on their cards. And are we referring to credit/debit cards or a customer loyalty card similar to a walgreens card?



-------------------------

Motivation for Entrepreneurs
Entre-Propel.com
JamesD

posts: 7

Jan 27, 2009 3:22 PM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Grocery stores have 40,000 items in stock.  Multiply that by the number of chains in your area.  Reviewed on a weekly basis?
 
Club stores have between 800-1500 items in stock (depends on the chain).  And their inventory changes frequently.  Not to mention that Sam`s and Costco try to carry different items than each other in the same category so comparisons are hard to make.
 
No grocery chain will "send" you pricing information on a weekly basis as it can make them look bad in comparison (plus they don`t have people to do that task available).
 
Convenience stores and drug stores are rarely price conscious except for holiday items and lead item specials.  Their niches are convenience (hence the name convenience store) and selection (along with pharmacist advice) in the drug stores.
 
In essence the only way to sell a service in this arena would be to sell advertising to local businesses on your site.  People will resist paying for information like this.  So your concept would really be selling ads to businesses so the information could be free to consumers.
 
Hope this gives another perspective to one of your concepts.  Good luck.
ckw1969

posts: 15

Jan 27, 2009 4:28 PM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Thank you for your replies.
 
To MattThomas:  Upromise allows its members to set up a profile. The profile includes any loyalty member cards to area convenience stores/grocery stores (Rite-Aid/ Giant Food etc) and your credit and debit cards (Visa, MasterCard, etc) the owner has. 
 
With their new ecoupon for groceries, you merely click on the coupons you want to use the next time you go the store. No downloading, no printing; the savings are reflected on your card and at the register. That`s brilliant for a several reasons: You don`t have to cut, organize or print coupons.  However it`s only for groceries, even though Upromise also offers discounts to retailers. I would to also offer ecoupons for retail stores. I hope that clarifies things a bit.
 
To James: We spend quite a bit of money on groceries and I think most of the time, we do so hazardly, because eating is a necessity.  I do realize some things are in some stores that are not in others.  And I have no intention of charging people for this (I plan to charge companies to advertise) After all, Coupon Mom and Upromise allow consumers to use these services for free, and I intend to do the same. However the economy has made me actually look at prices of things totally different.  Before I would throw things in my cart whether I had a coupon or not, regardless or price. Not so anymore. I have learned:
 
To question my loyalty: Where I live Prepperidge farm bread is 4.00 a LOAF (how INSANE is that?) no matter what store you go to. And they rarely have coupons.  So why am I still eating it? Would it kill me to try another loaf of bread? (My point here is that most people buy the same things over and over regardless of cost without considering a lower cost item.  What did the company do to get your loyalty?)
 
Things are Not What they seem: 98.6% of the time I would buy my medication from CVS, plop down my insurance card and never think that it might cost less at Giant, or Safeway or Rite-Aid.  However, two independent reports said the best place to your medication (if it was not generic) was Costco of all places.  I take two medications that are Tier 3 and do not come in generic.  Would it be worth the annual fee to Costco to get the medication cheaper? (I suffer from migraines and hypothyroidism, so my medications are "maintaintenance" medications -I need them) Granted not everyone is accessible to Costco. Not everyone has an illness like mine where they take meds everyday.  But these are the kinds of things I`m talking about.  No one I personally knows shops around for prices on their medication or their toilet paper. But we`ll go on Shopzilla and find the lowest price for an ipod or Amazon for a book - things we don`t necessarily need.
 
I also want to point what someone said years ago about comparison shopping, and this was before gas prices fluctuated: you can`t drive across town and spend 10.00 in gas trying to save 5.00.  I tend to stay out of the covenience store before because I notice that you pay for the conveniece, and the prices might be a little fluctuated.  So you have to do what makes sense for you and your situation - but like with everything else you need to have all the tools to do so. My goal to is give the consumer in my area the tools.
 
Cheers,
 
CK
ckw19691/27/2009 4:30 PM
sjohnson2

posts: 3

Jan 27, 2009 7:27 PM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Your first idea brings me more interest than the second.
However ... I agree with Matt ... in hoping there is an easier way than the barcode idea.
What if you narrow down the scope some to only the main grocery stores?
Don`t include every grocery retailer?
Sam .....


sjohnson21/27/2009 7:24 PM


-------------------------

power your world with a wind generator
ckw1969

posts: 15

Jan 27, 2009 8:39 PM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Thank you, Sam :) You, Matt and the first person I ran it by have given me a thumbs up, as it were. Which is a nice shot of confidence; at least 3 people think it sounds plausible..  As far as what to scan in: I don`t know. I`ve certainly have not bought everything in a grocery store.  But I think there are many things to consider
 
price
location
convenience
 
And while the Wholesalers are few and far between, they should not be ignored (in my area they get alot of traffic traffic).  For instance I mentioned Costco and the medication (they have the best prices).However, BJ`s is the only wholesaler that allows you to use manufacturer`s coupons.
 
I`m a single mom of 1 with a cat in an apartment.  I don`t go to wholesalers often. I don`t have the space or the need.  But for families of 3 or more, it might be worthwhile to pickup your:
toilet paper
femine care items
pet care items
baby care items
toiletries
canned food
 
Why? - Because you need them in a large quantity due to the size of your family.  Is it worth the annual 30.00 fee?  I think so.
 
That`s want I want to help families find out. But thanks again for your thoughts.  I am still in the planning stages.  And maybe James (and Matt and you) are right: there is just way to much data to put in.  But I want to give people the most information. So I will have to give that some thought.
 
Cheers,
 
CK
 
ckw19691/27/2009 8:57 PM
CraigL

posts: 9051

Jan 27, 2009 10:29 PM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Actually, I was going to say the first idea isn`t all that great, and I see I`m disagreeing with previous posts. :-)

But here`s the thing: Not so long ago I was doing fine, had lots of money, and never even bothered to look at prices in the grocery store. I should mention I love to cook and shop, and spent a lot of time in food stores.

Things got bad, then really bad. I not only had to look at prices, but soon had to develop a fundamentally different approach to shopping for food and groceries.

I discovered that I don`t care at all about weekly sales, ads, or even the price differentials between stores. What matters is to understand the buying cycle for each store so I can learn "close-dated" sale items. These are things with expiration dates, where the store will drastically cut the price 3 days before expiration.

None of these appear in any ads, they`re done only in the store. I also found that certain stores specialize in various items, but the only way to know that is by shopping them regularly. So one store is our "go-to" place for pork, where another is where to buy eggs and milk.

Additionally, and most importantly, by carrying around a database of current prices for my entire larder in my mind, I can easily find "instant deals" where a department manager wants to get rid of something quickly. We walked into a store at the right time, and saw Alaska king crab legs marked down to $4 for an entire package. They`d been frozen, and the expiration was approaching.

Ordinarily crab legs go for $15-20/package.

So the problem with the first idea is that it gives us a lot of information that really isn`t helpful, particularly as people begin having to pay close attention to their shopping and prices. It "appears" to be useful information, but it isn`t.
ckw1969

posts: 15

Jan 28, 2009 2:04 AM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Craig:
 
Thank you for your response.  The site is not necessarily geared towards  sales or weekly deals, although that certainly sweetens the pot: It`s about helping shoppers find the right shopping experience for them.
 
And I do appreciate that there are some people don`t care about prices, won`t cut and organize coupons and pay no attention to expiration dates and will throw whatever they like in their carts.  But for those who do, it`s about keeping the money in their pocket more when they can if they can.
 
As I mentioned earlier, for me and some of my peers, the recession, depression, Hell (because I think that`s where we are now) has made us rethink our spending behaviors. 
 
The goals is help people make better choices. If you know that at least three stores in your areas have all your the items you want, and can do a price comparison, the one that costs the less is the victor, I would usually say. I don`t think in the end it comes out if you have drive to several differant stores (and considering most people go to the store at least 3 times a  month), but that is for the family to decide. 
 
But I am glad to get your perspective, because I need to hear other people`s shopping experience. (You`re my first critic) Here, hands down the best place to shop is either Food Lion or Shoppers.  However not everyone is necessarily close to either store. So I wanted to have people base it on the shops in there area.
 
Also, the thing for me as I mentioned earlier was to given up loyalty to certain brands to eat cheaper.  Prepperidge Farm Bridge is 4.00 at ALL stores.  
 
And thank you for the information on buying cycles (it was in my mind, you make me remember - our area Safeway sells their whole roasts chickens for only 5.00, is the example I have, and is definately not in the circular)
 
But like the coupon mom site - I am not just going to give me people data, I am also going to give them information and resources and tools.  And if it reasonates, all the better. 
 
Cheers,
 
CK
CraigL

posts: 9051

Jan 29, 2009 3:22 AM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Hmm....we already know you`d have a major research project, ongoing, never ending.

What about modifying the actual implementation, but keeping the underlying idea----to help people food-shop smarter.

Why not build an information site, perhaps starting using blog software. Given the "article" orientation of blogs, you could easily write articles that would target particular aspects of this type of shopping.

You also could quickly insert articles about specials, deals, or reasons why one store is better than another for say, produce or bread or meat.

The blog would automatically provide searching, categories, and all sorts of things similar to a database, and you wouldn`t have to start from scratch.

Some articles could be about topical concepts, like close-dated purchasing, bulk shopping, how to use a freezer, portion management and things like that. Others could be targeted to shopping for singles or older couples, recipes for large families, and things like how to make a whole turkey into meals for a family for a month.

It`d sure reduce your research, and would give you almost an instant "on" capability, to test the idea and what would be important for a dedicated Web site.
MattThomas

posts: 203

Jan 29, 2009 3:59 PM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
No grocery chain will "send" you pricing information on a weekly basis as it can make them look bad in comparison


Or it can make them look good...

Think about it this way, if you are looking for the best prices possible, you still aren`t going to run to five different grocery stores to take advantage of all the sales, you are going to go to the one that offers the biggest savings from the most sales.

If there is enough viewership, grocery stores may very well send you their prices since the exposure is good for business, especially if they are running more sales than the competitor. Their price of, say bread may not be better but their prices of five other different items might be.

That said, it might actually be useful to include kind of a "total savings analyzer" on the site, where the user would enter their grocery list, and the site searches the pricing for the list. It spits out the grocery store that would yield the biggest savings based on the entire list.


-------------------------

Motivation for Entrepreneurs
Entre-Propel.com
Page of 1
Post Reply
 
.
Advertisement

Keep the Community Clean!

  • StartupNation forums should be used as a platform to learn, educate others, share stories, tips & tricks and to provide constructive feedback.
  • Please do not use the Forums for advertising & blatant self-promotion.
  • Please be respectful to other members and refrain from personal attacks and vulgar language.
  • StartupNation reserves the right to delete any message, reply, and/or member who violates our terms of use.
Read full terms of use
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement