what about some type of certificate or award printed out that simply says thanks and we honor your commitment and personal drive. Of course you`ll toss something in about how your credit union supports their efforts. It`s easy and can be printed in time. If it`s done right I could see them framing it in their home office etc.
Hey my wife and I own a salon Downriver (sakora salon), in Brownstown Mi. Where`s your credit union at? I guess it is a small world after all!
I love Todd`s idea of a certificate. You could also post something on a password-protected portion of your website and give the password to the appropriate members. This could be a discount coupon for a local spa, coffee shop, amusement park, etc., a special message from the executive team, or even a note stating that they will be receiving a special gift soon.
Also, you don`t have much time, but perhaps you could buy gift cards from local retailers and include these with the certificates. There are also promotional product companies that help businesses with their last-minute needs (try Benison International Group, www.benisoninternational.com).