Find us elsewhere
Join Now Member Login

Need Help Protecting My Website Idea

 
New Topic
Post Reply
Follow Topic
« Prev Page of 4 Next »
  • Author
  • Message
 
Nuevolution

posts: 1223

May 11, 2006 4:05 AM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Calvin and Watson,
There is no reason for you to venture in with anyone. What you need to do is, have them sign a contractoral agreement. In the agreement you must address that anything they develop for you while they are being paid by your company will remain property of your company. That they can not duplicate or sell of your idea to anyone without written permission by your company, and in the case they do "the develper will have to pay your company for any damages caused by the outcome" I have a few contractural agreements that you may use. All you need to do is take it to a business lawyer so they can modify it to your advantage. If you don`t have cash to pay for a lawyer, join the pre-paid legal services, with the small business package and they will revise the document for you free. It`s a paid member ship so for like $42.00 a month you have all the legal help you need.


-------------------------

Edgar Monroy
Web Developer / Owner / Consultant
When starting your own business the need to "know-how" is greater than money!
http://www.nuevolution.net
Watson75

posts: 53

May 12, 2006 3:46 AM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote

Thanks for your reply Nuevolution.

[quote]There is no reason for you to venture in with anyone.[/quote]

What exactly do you mean by this? After all, the whole foundation of my plans revolve around "venturing" in with someone. Isn`t forming a contract and working together to create a site a venture?

And yes, Calvin, it`s interesting to see that you`re in the same exactly situation as me. I tried searching the web to answers to my questions, looking in books etc., and really couldn`t find what I was looking for. So I figured I better start asking around. So Calvin, by what means do you plan on going about getting your site developed?



-------------------------

I want to know, if I can live with what I know. And only that.
starpointe

posts: 46

May 12, 2006 3:45 PM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Well Watson,

I`ll tell you what one of my marketing law professors told me in college.  "No matter how new or unique you think your idea is, I guarantee you`re not the first one to think of it."  How many times have you thought, "Gosh if only there were a toilet that would..."  But have you actually done anything about it?  Probably not.  The secret is that 99.9% of people think of ideas but don`t put in the work to make them successful.  Non-competes and nda`s are great but in the end are nearly useless since most of the people you talk with will simply say, "That`s awesome, you should do that."

Now I understand your situation in that you will need to hire a website development company and you will end up divulging you idea/processes to them.  In this case a non-compete and nda are a must.  However, chances are they are still too busy with what they`re good at to try to start a new business based on your idea.  Especially if you hire a company with lots to do.  (Freelancers have more free time and would be more likely to waste time pondering how to start a business like yours...especially since they`re freelancers which means they are already entrepreneurial.) 

I suggest just going for it.  Find a development company that you`re comfortable with, (take the time to talk with them and learn their philosophies) and go with them.  Have them sign all the prerequisite paperwork and then go to work.  You`re better off doing something and taking a risk than to do nothing and never know.



-------------------------

Ryan J StarPointe Marketing Website Development, Hosting & Marketing Consulting
Nuevolution

posts: 1223

May 12, 2006 3:59 PM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote

What I mean by ventureing is;
first of all, you don`t need to become partners with a web designer in order to protect your idea. What I meant was make sure you have to right contracts in place when you decide to have your web site developed.
But like Starpointe`s teacher said "There is no guarantee that you are the first to think about the idea" What makes the difference is, who beats who to launching the idea. The one that gets the idea out there first is the innovator, the rest are just tag alongs.. Look at myspace.com.. Thomas was the innovator.. All the Myspace tag alongs are just trying to cash in on his idea.. Now some how everyone has some sorda of space online.. myadultspace, mybusspace.. everyone wants to cash in on his idea... So, the best thing to do is don`t worry about who will copy you, worry about getting your idea out there.

 



-------------------------

Edgar Monroy
Web Developer / Owner / Consultant
When starting your own business the need to "know-how" is greater than money!
http://www.nuevolution.net
starpointe

posts: 46

May 12, 2006 4:17 PM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Good call.  I do want to expound on one thing...there is no shame in being a `tag-along`.  Even MySpace wasn`t the first to develop a social networking system.  All it takes to run a successful business is to do something 10% better than someone else.  There are very few new inventions anymore...but innovators are having a hayday taking pre-existing ideas and making them just a little better.

So in the end, I would say the keys to being successful are:
1. Be first (if possible)
2. Be 10% better than the alternative
3. Constantly innovate to stay 10% better.



-------------------------

Ryan J StarPointe Marketing Website Development, Hosting & Marketing Consulting
Nuevolution

posts: 1223

May 12, 2006 4:42 PM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Good call.  I do want to expound on one thing...there is no shame in being a `tag-along`.  Even MySpace wasn`t the first to develop a social networking system.  All it takes to run a successful business is to do something 10% better than someone else.  There are very few new inventions anymore...but innovators are having a hayday taking pre-existing ideas and making them just a little better.

So in the end, I would say the keys to being successful are:
1. Be first (if possible)
2. Be 10% better than the alternative
3. Constantly innovate to stay 10% better.


<b>Of course there is no shame in being a tag-along</b>
But why be a tag-along? Why not innovate? discover and dominate a certain market. Now as far as Myspace.com, he might of not been the first to create a social portal, but he was the first to offer a a customized "Page" Allowing the users to customize their "Space" and retain them, now don`t you like the feature of browsing profiles and requesting an "ADD ME" link? I think that is neat. Not to mention the company is worth over 580 Million.. That is astonishing to see. I guess that is why AOL annouced lay-offs this week... AOL was an innovator but made it to cluttered, was bought out by religious freak and Look where it got them. Staying focused is the key to survival and staying in business.
My other advise is, you are right about inventions. I think almost everything has been invented already, now we need solutions. I think there is more money in solutions that there is in innovating...


-------------------------

Edgar Monroy
Web Developer / Owner / Consultant
When starting your own business the need to "know-how" is greater than money!
http://www.nuevolution.net
calvin

posts: 39

May 14, 2006 3:42 PM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote

uh oh... please delete this post.  where`s the delete function?

 



-------------------------

calvin1214@hotmail.com

calvin

posts: 39

May 14, 2006 3:43 PM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote

Thanks for your reply Nuevolution.

[quote]There is no reason for you to venture in with anyone.[/quote]

What exactly do you mean by this? After all, the whole foundation of my plans revolve around "venturing" in with someone. Isn`t forming a contract and working together to create a site a venture?

And yes, Calvin, it`s interesting to see that you`re in the same exactly situation as me. I tried searching the web to answers to my questions, looking in books etc., and really couldn`t find what I was looking for. So I figured I better start asking around. So Calvin, by what means do you plan on going about getting your site developed?

honestly... i`m at a weird stage in my process at right now.  i`m at the point where i have to start putting money into the biz.  i`m trying to find out if i need to incorporate first before i start putting money into the project... or can i put my personal money in now and get it written off as a biz expense after i incorporate for tax purposes.  so i need to find that out before i do anything.

next... since my idea is an online auction idea, there are lots of pre-programmed software aps for me out there.  i spoke to a couple of web developers and they said it would be much cheaper to modify a pre-built auction site than to build one from scratch.  so once i figure out this finance issue... i need to get my site up and running.

as far as protecting my idea... i think it would be extremely tough.  my online auction site offers a service for a specific niche...so it would be unique... but not necessarily patentable (from what i know).  for example, it`s like developing an auction site specifically for `69 ford mustangs if there really is a market for it out there.  the only thing i think i can patent is the functionality of my site. specific fuctions like a "buy me now" function or something like that.

i think once i get my site up and running to the point where i am happy with it, i will take it to a patent/biz lawyer to see what unique functions i`ve developed for the site i can pantent.  

hopefully this is the right way to approach this... anybody with any suggestions?  i may need to start a new thread for help  

 



-------------------------

calvin1214@hotmail.com

Watson75

posts: 53

Jun 01, 2006 12:24 AM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote

[quote] i`m trying to find out if i need to incorporate first before i start putting money into the project... [/quote]

Well, I`m facing a similar situation myself. I`m at the point where I have to look at what type of business entities I could form. I`ve been reading up about Sole Proprietorships, LLC`s as well as Corporations. There`s the obvious truth that once the website is up and running, it goes without saying that it will have to run under the form of some business. However, I think it would be beneficial for me to tie my idea and venture with some form of business, even during the developement and early stages that I`m in.

From what I understand, a Sole Proprietorship isn`t much of anything, and all you really do is file for a name down at your local town offices. I even read that you don`t have to file for papers at all, and pretty much just say abra cadabra I`m a Sole Proprietor... and you are. This makes me leery of the whole idea. I want something that`s a little more legal and professional.

Basically, when I pitch my idea to others and have them sign NDA`s and such, I think it would be much better to tie it to a business entity, perhaps even essential? And of course, when I find a partner and we write up pre negotiated contracts relating to the stake in the venture, it just seems like there would have to be some legal business entity involved.

1. For example, `said party agrees not to disclose any information to outside sources that belong to [business entity].

or

2. `All work done by said party in relation to legal documents which outline the design of the website belong solely to [business entity], and any revenue generated by [business entity] will be split with said party in the following manner [...].  

With the first instance involving a NDA and the second instance involving pre-negotiated business contracts and both instances involving the business entity owned by me, and the documents pertainining to the design of the site associated with the business entity.

I`m also wondering if for whatever reason I chose a Sole Proprietorship to start out, if that could eventually be converted into a Corporation. Nothing I have read addresses this issue. Also, is there one business entity you guys would recommend over another in a situation like mine?

As you can tell, I`m clearly not very sure of any of this, and really do need some enlightening related to these issues. If anyone is more informed on the subject matter than me, I`d greatly appreciate any help given. Thank you all for your help with my endeavor.



-------------------------

I want to know, if I can live with what I know. And only that.
executeksearch

posts: 136

Jun 01, 2006 1:05 AM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Watson75-

A Sole proprietorship can easily be turned into a formal corporation at anytime. You just have to pay the filing fees and usually some lawyer fees unless of course you utilize an "Incorporation" company. That is a company that fills out all the necessary paperwork for you. In that case you will still probably want a lawyer to look over the documents.

As far as what  I personally would recommend for type of corporation. Well, that largely depends on if you plan on soliciting Venture Capital at some point. If you do then I would recommend a "C" corporation. If you do that, make sure that in your articles of incorporation that you authorize a substantial amount of shares of stock for your company (for example: 10M common stock and 2M preferred stock). This will give you some options for investors later on. If you don`t do this at the time of incorporation it will cost you another filing fee for an "amendment to articles of incorporation". I am going through this right now, so this information is from experience!

If you do not plan on soliciting investors at some point then I would suggest an "S" corporation. This gives you the same protection as a "C" corporation without much of the regulations and the possablility of "Double Taxation". An LLC is a popular choice as well, however, I personally feel that an LLC is not much better than a Sole Proprietor.

To answer calvins question as far as should you go ahead and put personal funds into the "venture" and then incorporate and possibly write off the expenses after incorporation. The Fact is when you incorporate, in your by-laws, there is a section that describes "Start-up costs". This would include anything that you have personally put into getting this venture off of the ground ( for example: Incorporation fees, Research and Development, Equipment that you have personally donated to the venture and so on). So to answer your question, it really doesn`t matter when you incorporate or when you start putting money into the venture, because as soon as you incorporate or start developing a product or website you have already put money into the venture and it will be reflected as a business expense sometime down the line anyway.

I hope that this was helpful. Best wishes to you both!

Ken~
« Prev Page of 4 Next »
Post Reply
 
.
Advertisement

Keep the Community Clean!

  • StartupNation forums should be used as a platform to learn, educate others, share stories, tips & tricks and to provide constructive feedback.
  • Please do not use the Forums for advertising & blatant self-promotion.
  • Please be respectful to other members and refrain from personal attacks and vulgar language.
  • StartupNation reserves the right to delete any message, reply, and/or member who violates our terms of use.
Read full terms of use
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement