Find us elsewhere
Join Now Member Login

First Web Site--Critiques Welcome

 
New Topic
Post Reply
Follow Topic
Page of 1
  • Author
  • Message
 
MimiRogers

posts: 23

Jul 20, 2008 3:53 PM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Hi,
 
I have received a lot of good ideas to work with right now. When I have a more finished product I will update this link.
 
 
MimiRogers7/21/2008 10:01 AM
Videography

posts: 672

Jul 21, 2008 12:00 AM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
OK, here`s some notes I made while looking at your site:


On your nav bar: "Frequently Asked Question"
Only One?

In your home page: "OCR (Optical Character Resolution) "  
OCR is Optical Character Recognition.

Is this a spelling error, or a new term: "typographycopy editing"


In your About Me page: "...central stenographic pool for the University faculty and staff."
Which university?

Don`t use underlined text - it looks too much like it should be a link.

It is considered to be bad typography to have more than two fonts on any document.  Your home page has four, five or six, depending on how you count fonts.  Inside the blue box, you have a san-serif font, but the highlight of your name is a serifed font.  Your "Services Offered" starts in sans-serif in the header, followed by serif font in the bullet-pointed list, then your next list is san-serif, black and a different paragraph spacing, followed by a blue line of serifed text, then another header in sans serif...  You get the picture, your typography is all over the place.

Now, back to the text in the box...  It`s very weak.  Lots of passive voice.  You need to get rid of the passive voice and be more forceful about your services.  This is where you need to present a solution to the viewer`s problems.  Try this:

"You have worked weeks or months on the manuscript for that perfect book, journal article, manual, brochure, newsletter or in-house publication.  Now you need Crescent Moon DPD to provide the professional assistance with an eye for detail to prepare a professional document ready for publication. You will receive personal attention to every detail of the project from beginning to end."

(Publication and Printing are the same thing; Book and Textbook are redundant, which is why I dropped them).

Notice the difference?  In my suggested text, you are not *asking* for their business, you are *telling* them why they need you.

You could use an image of a pile of handwritten pages that represents the manuscript for "War and Peace, Episode Two" that needs to be transcribed into a computer-friendly document.

Personally, I would get rid of the box.

By the way, the phrase "Desktop Publishing" is sooooo twentieth-century.  



-------------------------

Steve Mann
Internet Videographer
MannMade Digital Video
My Email


CraigL

posts: 9051

Jul 21, 2008 2:35 AM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Hi Susan :-)
I think I`d either remove the empty "Publications" page, or put some titles in there. As to the "TEST" tab, that sounds either like you`re using it to test Web programming, or it`s some sort of test for people to take. You likely could do better with something like "Contact Us."

The overall front page is too "big," for want of a better word. I`m using a high-resolution LCD panel, and it`s big on my screen. Ergo, it likely is huge on a typical monitor...even though they`re changing these days.

Here`s a bugaboo of mine, where you have a "Welcome to" headline on your page. Of course I`m welcome, so it`s redundant. Then to have it in blue, underlined, I just assumed it was a link to somewhere else.

The page title should at least be changed to "Crescent Moon - Desktop Publishing Services." Right now, with "Home," you don`t get much benefit from search engines.

Right now, your meta description is 215 characters long.  Google only shows 150 characters in the results page blurbs, and a "..." if there`s more. With good copywriting, you should be able to get exactly 150 characters.

All in all, it`s pretty clear what you do, but I`m not so sure what it is you`re offering. There`s not much persuasive content describing my problem, and how you`re going to solve that problem. How much DTP do I do?

What`s your target market? How do you know they have a problem? What is that problem? And how will you solve that problem?

What I`d like to see would be a Web page that highlights the skills you`re offering in design, as a DTP expert. The Web page looks pretty simplistic, so to speak, and I found myself thinking that if this is how you do other documents, I`ll just use In-Design or something like it. See?

So if you can`t do it, then be sure to hire someone who can bring your vision to the Web, not only to desktop publishing. Otherwise, I think you`re hurting yourself in the layout and design here.
CraigL2008-7-21 2:37:23
MimiRogers

posts: 23

Jul 21, 2008 9:46 AM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Thank you all for the suggestions and comments. The blank pages are there as I have not added the content yet. I suppose I should delete them until I am ready to add something. I plan to put the books I have done, which I have in word format, into an e-Book or something similar. So I will definitely take all the suggestions in here and make some changes.
 
One problem that is holding me back is I`m using Office Live Small Business and don`t know a lot about HTML, etc. Although I am learning. I simply need to get the basics up for now and then as I learn more programming I can go in and make changes later. I`ve read to keep the content changing from time to time to it doesn`t go stale, so I will keep working on it.
 
Thank you so much for your ideas. They are of a great help to me.
 
When I have a more finished product, which I am hoping will be by the end of the week, I will definitely post a new topic and get your opinions.
MimiRogers7/21/2008 10:02 AM
MimiRogers

posts: 23

Jul 21, 2008 9:53 AM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Hi Craig,
 
Hi Susan :-)
I think I`d either remove the empty "Publications" page, or put some titles in there. As to the "TEST" tab, that sounds either like you`re using it to test Web programming, or it`s some sort of test for people to take. You likely could do better with something like "Contact Us."  {Those pages are blank as I have not added anything yet. I will remove those pages until I have the text ready.}

The overall front page is too "big," for want of a better word. I`m using a high-resolution LCD panel, and it`s big on my screen. Ergo, it likely is huge on a typical monitor...even though they`re changing these days.  {Thank you for letting me know this, and I will be making some adjustments.}

Here`s a bugaboo of mine, where you have a "Welcome to" headline on your page. Of course I`m welcome, so it`s redundant. Then to have it in blue, underlined, I just assumed it was a link to somewhere else.  {Good idea!}

The page title should at least be changed to "Crescent Moon - Desktop Publishing Services." Right now, with "Home," you don`t get much benefit from search engines. {Good idea again!}

Right now, your meta description is 215 characters long.  Google only shows 150 characters in the results page blurbs, and a "..." if there`s more. With good copywriting, you should be able to get exactly 150 characters.
{All the rest below is extremely helpful to me. Thank you very much}
All in all, it`s pretty clear what you do, but I`m not so sure what it is you`re offering. There`s not much persuasive content describing my problem, and how you`re going to solve that problem. How much DTP do I do?

What`s your target market? How do you know they have a problem? What is that problem? And how will you solve that problem?

What I`d like to see would be a Web page that highlights the skills you`re offering in design, as a DTP expert. The Web page looks pretty simplistic, so to speak, and I found myself thinking that if this is how you do other documents, I`ll just use In-Design or something like it. See?

So if you can`t do it, then be sure to hire someone who can bring your vision to the Web, not only to desktop publishing. Otherwise, I think you`re hurting yourself in the layout and design here.
 
MimiRogers

posts: 23

Jul 21, 2008 9:55 AM ET    Quote  Report Abuse
Points: 0   Vote
Hi Videography,
Thank you for your ideas.
OK, here`s some notes I made while looking at your site:


On your nav bar: "Frequently Asked Question"
Only One? {I will remove this page for now as I have not gotten to entering any text yet}

In your About Me page: "...central stenographic pool for the University faculty and staff."
Which university?

Don`t use underlined text - it looks too much like it should be a link.

It is considered to be bad typography to have more than two fonts on any document.  Your home page has four, five or six, depending on how you count fonts.  Inside the blue box, you have a san-serif font, but the highlight of your name is a serifed font.  Your "Services Offered" starts in sans-serif in the header, followed by serif font in the bullet-pointed list, then your next list is san-serif, black and a different paragraph spacing, followed by a blue line of serifed text, then another header in sans serif...  You get the picture, your typography is all over the place.

Now, back to the text in the box...  It`s very weak.  Lots of passive voice.  You need to get rid of the passive voice and be more forceful about your services.  This is where you need to present a solution to the viewer`s problems.  Try this:

"You have worked weeks or months on the manuscript for that perfect book, journal article, manual, brochure, newsletter or in-house publication.  Now you need Crescent Moon DPD to provide the professional assistance with an eye for detail to prepare a professional document ready for publication. You will receive personal attention to every detail of the project from beginning to end."

(Publication and Printing are the same thing; Book and Textbook are redundant, which is why I dropped them).

Notice the difference?  In my suggested text, you are not *asking* for their business, you are *telling* them why they need you.

You could use an image of a pile of handwritten pages that represents the manuscript for "War and Peace, Episode Two" that needs to be transcribed into a computer-friendly document.

Personally, I would get rid of the box.

By the way, the phrase "Desktop Publishing" is sooooo twentieth-century.  {I see that now; however, my website is already named so I don`t see any other way of getting away from it, but I will take your suggestions and make some changes.}


Page of 1
Post Reply
 
.
Advertisement

Keep the Community Clean!

  • StartupNation forums should be used as a platform to learn, educate others, share stories, tips & tricks and to provide constructive feedback.
  • Please do not use the Forums for advertising & blatant self-promotion.
  • Please be respectful to other members and refrain from personal attacks and vulgar language.
  • StartupNation reserves the right to delete any message, reply, and/or member who violates our terms of use.
Read full terms of use
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement